Masterson Staffing Solutions

Top Mistakes That Hiring Managers Make (And How to Avoid Them)

September 20th, 2019 Written by: Masterson Staffing Solutions

Not all companies follow the same hiring process. This isn’t inherently a bad thing, as the values and traits they look for in an ideal candidate will vary. What can be troubling is that the hiring process can draw out for weeks, even months. This creates a frustrating experience for the job seeker and leaves a position vacant. Additional problems that arise from poorly managed recruitment might include inaccurate job postings and unfulfilling interviews.

A bad hiring experience can affect your organization’s performance. Fortunately there are ways to prevent mistakes, and recognizing the following common errors that hiring managers make will save you time and money during the recruitment process.

Being Unresponsive

Only 40 percent of those who apply for job postings receive a response. Whether or not you are actively seeking new talent, being unresponsive is never a good way to represent your company. To protect your image and attract high quality talent, be amicable and communicative.

If an individual inquires about open job positions (even if the company isn’t actively recruiting), offer a response to check in another time. The applicants should also be made aware of rejection.

Pursuing an Unrealistic “Ideal Candidate”

The candidate who fits the job correctly – by having just enough experience, education and qualifying skills – is referred to as a “purple squirrel”. This is a theoretical candidate who marks all of the boxes of qualifications and will fit in perfectly with the company’s culture. However, just as purple squirrels don’t genuinely exist in nature, they most likely don’t exist in the workplace. There is not going to be a candidate who fits all of your requirements. The description of the perfect candidate is often far too unrealistic, and that can harm your hiring efforts.

If you’re discouraged from hearing that, understand how discouraged a potentially fantastic job seeker is when looking at your job posting. No single career path is linear, and not every candidate is going to share the same experience. You might even find that there are other skills or traits you would love in a candidate after interviewing him or her. Of course the job posting should outline the desirable experience and qualifications, but a hiring manager should have an open mind and not solely seek applicants that matches every criterion.

A Poorly Executed Onboarding Process

The hiring manager has a massive impact on the onboarding process. The earliest stages of onboarding begins with the hiring manager. He/she will act as a guide and welcome a new employee to the company. The onboarding process should by aided not only by the hiring manager, but by anyone who was involved in the hiring process. This could be directors and supervisors from different departments or anyone from human resources (HR).

A bond between the newly hired employee and those who were part of the onboarding process should begin from day one. Before the candidate’s first day, preparations for onboarding should have started. Any materials or documents necessary for onboarding should be prepared in advance, and they should be easily shareable and accessible to other employees. You should also pass this information off to the newly hired employee before their first day so they can get acquainted with the organization and departments early on.

There is power in selecting future employees. It is a privilege, and the responsibility should be taken seriously. Taking the time to prepare the interviewing and onboarding process will allow hiring managers to avoid common mistakes, and it will ensure that your company will find the right candidate for the job.

Are you a hiring manager in need of help? Masterson Staffing Solutions has been working with the nation’s top companies to fulfill their staffing needs and matching job seekers with employment opportunities for more than 50 years. Don’t hesitate to contact us by phone, online or by visiting one of our office locations.

More Stories

masterson staffing solutions

Businesses Are Placing an Emphasis on Workplace Diversity

The concept of hiring a diverse group of talent has been a growing priority for many businesses, because historically, workplace demographics had been largely homogenous. So what is the definition of workplace diversity and why are recruiters putting an emphasis on it? In order to answer that, we need to first define the different categories … Continue reading Businesses Are Placing an Emphasis on Workplace Diversity

masterson staffing solutions

9 Tips for a Strong Video Job Interview During COVID-19

If you’re new to working remotely, you may still be adjusting to the way we communicate during COVID-19. While some states are slowly returning back to work, how we conduct business may change. One of the biggest changes that may take place is an increase in video interviews, which can be daunting if you’re the … Continue reading 9 Tips for a Strong Video Job Interview During COVID-19

masterson staffing solutions

How to Get Over Job Search Fatigue

When you’re having trouble finding a job, it can be difficult to not feel burnt out. Many people get discouraged after trying for weeks, even months, and just want to give up. If this is the case you’re facing, know that it is extremely common and that there are ways to get out of it. … Continue reading How to Get Over Job Search Fatigue

Job Fairs

Join us for exciting keynotes, informative sessions, and networking with hundreds of peers and leaders

Learn more

Ignite your career and surge ahead with Masterson Staffing.Apply Nowmasterson staffing solutions

>>